90 percent of everything : Usability Blog
Written by Harry Brignull

Archive for February, 2005

Who still thinks modal dialogs are a good idea…

February 20th, 2005 by Andy BakerAdd a comment

This is beginning to sound like I’m picking on Adobe. Photoshop is one of my favourite tools (although it has some strange wrinkles - hiding masses of functionality behind strange keyboard modifiers?) and generally I think it’s fairly usable

This means that the remaining bits of cruft in the interface stick out like a sore thumb.

So. modal dialog boxes. The ones that pop up to tell you something and block you doing other things until you click OK.

What they are popping up to tell you had better be important as they disrupt your train of thought. When you are working fast on something repetitive you find your self clicking on another area of the screen, getting that annoying ‘ding’ noise until another part of your brain manages to notice that one of the little buggers has popped up and is blocking what you are trying to do.

This is fine if the message is ‘Warning! Doing this will kill all your friends. Please turn on the ‘Allow application to kill all my friends’ preference if you wish to allow this.’

Anything less urgent than this should be communicating with you in a way that doesn’t make you stop what you are doing. A status bar message or an informational popup somewhere away from your cursor.

My favourite Photoshop rage moment is when you are

There use was rampant in the past but they happily went the way of human sacrifice and coin-operated electricity meters.

There are still some left.

(note to reader. I started writing this. Got distracted and now can’t remember where I saw the modal dialog that annoyed me in the first place. I thought I’d post this anyway as I need to up my average and someone might come along and find it for me…)

Better lock up your documentation. You never know …

February 16th, 2005 by Andy BakerAdd a comment

Adobe installs some fairly good scripting documentation along with Photoshop.

In PDF format.

And they wisely make use of PDF’s built in security permissions to prevent you copying and pasting any of the code samples in the PDF.

I mean how are we ever going to learn without being forced to type it all out again?

(Oh and breaking the security on those PDF’s takes about 1 second with the right software)

Rolling your own help functionality

February 15th, 2005 by Andy BakerAdd a comment

Note to software companies. Despite the fairly acceptable Windows help file format you may feel the need to write your own.

If you do this and yours is crappier than the effort-free alternative then congratulations on creating lots of pointless work for yourself. Feel free to come round to my house and do the hoovering when you are done.

Inspired by Flash MX, various Adobe products and many others that I have forgotten.